If the goal was to provide a framework and arguments, it's really impressive, and the search papers are quite relevant. He read the dataset and understood it, which I think is already quite remarkable. He managed to tie the logic together with the relationship to the dataset.
How about plotting from the CSV? PaperGen made some very relevant plots, though not many. PaperGen read and understood the dataset.
Overall I rate 80/100. If 100 is the answer given by the prof.